Preliminary hearing · Court location

Central Court vs. Your Local Magisterial District Court in Pennsylvania

The difference is where the hearing happens, which judge hears it, and which procedure controls the next step.

Free & confidential · Usually a same-day callback

  • Practicing since 2001
  • Member, National College for DUI Defense (NCDD)
  • Five-star reviewed
  • BBB A+ Rated

The short answer

The statewide default is that your preliminary hearing happens at the magisterial district court whose district covers where the charges were filed. Some counties instead route some or all preliminary hearings to a single centralized session called Central Court. Which one applies to you depends on your county and, in some counties, on your charge.

The statewide default and the central-court exception

Pa.R.Crim.P. 131(A)(3) supplies the default and its own exception: "All hearings and summary trials before the issuing authority shall be held publicly at the issuing authority's established office. For reasons of emergency, security, size, or in the interests of justice, the president judge, or the president judge's designee, may order that a hearing or hearings, or a trial or trials, be held in another more suitable location within the judicial district." The creation of a central court is a separate route, governed by Rule 131(B), and other arrangements may apply in a given judicial district.[1]

Pa.R.Crim.P. 131(B) governs the creation of central courts, and it is not a local administrative decision. The president judge must give at least 30 days' public notice and invite written comment, collect a written statement from every affected magisterial district judge, and petition the Administrative Office of Pennsylvania Courts with an assessment of the effect on public access to the courts and of the fiscal impact. The AOPC then makes a recommendation and "the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania shall decide whether to approve the petition." Rule 131(B)(3) also requires that any change not diminish the equitable distribution of cases among the county's magisterial district judges and not restrict public access to the courts. That procedure was added by the November 14, 2022 amendment, and the Rule 131 Comment preserves what came before it: "This rule is not intended to reverse existing orders relocating magisterial district judge proceedings to a central court." Several Pennsylvania central courts predate the current procedure.[1]

What actually differs for a defendant

IssueLocal magisterial district courtCentral Court
Where the hearing is heldAt the issuing authority's established office under the statewide default.At the county's centralized session when the county routes the case there.
Which judge hears itThe magisterial district judge of the magisterial district court covering the place the offense is alleged to have occurred.In counties whose central court predates the current rule, a rotating magisterial district judge who did not issue the charges may hear it. Rule 131(B)(3)(c) now bars any new arrangement in which an elected magisterial district judge hears cases from outside his or her district on a regularly scheduled basis; the Rule 131 Comment preserves orders that already existed.
How a continuance is requestedThrough the local magisterial district court's procedure.Through the county's Central Court procedure, which may still send the request to the issuing judge.
Which charges are routed thereThe local court handles the case under the default arrangement.Counties may route all felony and misdemeanor arrests, only DUI cases, or another published category.
TravelThe hearing is at magisterial district court covering the place the offense is alleged to have occurred.The centralized location can change how far the defendant has to travel.

What six counties publish — and why your county may not be here

CountyPublished preliminary-hearing arrangement
Franklin CountyCentralizes preliminary hearings for "all felony and misdemeanor arrests" at Central Court, Courtroom six, Franklin County Judicial Center, Chambersburg, each Tuesday, or Thursday when Tuesday is a legal holiday. Franklin County publishes that its Central Court "was established on January 29, 2001 pursuant to Pa.R.Crim.P. Rule 131(B)." That is the county's own characterization; Rule 131 was renumbered from Rule 22 effective April 1, 2001, and the Rule 131(B) petition procedure dates from a November 14, 2022 amendment. The Rule 131 Comment preserves pre-existing arrangements. This page makes no further representation about how or on what basis Franklin County's Central Court was approved. Two magisterial district judges rotate. Continuances go in writing to the issuing magisterial district judge.
Cumberland CountyPublishes that "Cumberland County's Central Court focuses on DUI cases" and that court is held on the 5th floor of the Main Courthouse, 1 Courthouse Square, Carlisle. Its published Central Court procedures address DUI court cases; they do not direct other charges to Central Court.
Lancaster CountyCentralizes DUI preliminary hearings in DUI Central Court, adopted by Administrative Order CP-36-AD-0000027-2015 (August 18, 2015). The court's 2026 calendar lists "DUI Court – Courtroom A" on twenty-six dates in Courtroom A, second floor, Lancaster County Courthouse, 50 North Duke Street. Non-DUI charges stay at the magisterial district court.
Dauphin CountyThe county designates a Central Court facility, district 12-0-01, at 501 Mall Road. The county does not publish what case types are routed there.
York CountyYork County publishes no order or policy creating a centralized DUI preliminary-hearing session, and none appears in the Pennsylvania Bulletin. Preliminary hearings are held at the magisterial district court covering the place the offense is alleged to have occurred.
Northumberland CountyNorthumberland County does not appear to publish any central-court arrangement for preliminary hearings.

These six counties are examples, not a complete list. Pennsylvania has 67 counties, and others operate central courts that are not described here; a county's arrangement can also change. The notice a defendant receives is the authority for where to appear. An attorney can confirm how this applies to a particular case.

Why the difference matters practically

  • · A rotating judge who did not issue the charges may approach the case differently.
  • · The continuance path is different, and getting it wrong is how people miss hearings.
  • · The travel burden shifts when the hearing moves to a centralized location.

If a hearing is missed, Pa.R.Crim.P. 543(D) supplies different outcomes depending on notice and cause. See what happens if you miss a preliminary hearing in Pennsylvania.

County guides and related pages

FAQ

Frequently asked questions.

Common questions about Central Court and local magisterial district courts.

  • It depends on the county and, in some counties, on the charge. The six counties below are examples, not a complete list — Pennsylvania has 67 counties, and others operate central courts not described here. Franklin centralizes preliminary hearings for all felony and misdemeanor arrests; Cumberland and Lancaster publish DUI-focused arrangements; Dauphin designates a Central Court facility but does not publish what case types go there; York and Northumberland publish no central-court arrangement for preliminary hearings. If your county is not listed, that means this page does not cover it, not that it has no central court. Counties change these arrangements, so the notice you receive is the authority for where to appear.

  • It is a centralized session for proceedings that would otherwise be held at the issuing authority's established office, rather than a different level of criminal court. Pa.R.Crim.P. 131(B) governs the creation of central courts.

  • Under the statewide default, the hearing is at the issuing authority's established office. In counties whose central court predates the current rule, a rotating magisterial district judge who did not issue the charges may hear it. Rule 131(B)(3)(c) now bars any new arrangement in which an elected magisterial district judge hears cases from outside his or her district on a regularly scheduled basis; the Rule 131 Comment preserves orders that already existed. Franklin County, for example, assigns two magisterial district judges on a rotating schedule to each Central Court day.

  • Follow the county's specific procedure. Franklin County requires a written request by email or fax to the issuing magisterial district judge, who decides after conferring with the district attorney and/or defense attorney. Do not assume the Central Court coordinator or rotating judge decides the request. An attorney can confirm the procedure for a particular case.

  • The notice a defendant receives is the authority for where to appear. Counties change these arrangements, and an attorney can confirm how the current arrangement applies to a particular case.

Sources & statutory citations

  1. [1]Pa.R.Crim.P. 131 — amended November 14, 2022, effective in 30 days, 52 Pa.B. 7252. Rule 131(B) governs the creation of central courts and requires the president judge to petition the Administrative Office of Pennsylvania Courts, with the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania making the ultimate decision. The Comment states that the rule "is not intended to reverse existing orders relocating magisterial district judge proceedings to a central court." Rule 131(A)(3) provides that hearings before an issuing authority shall be held publicly at the issuing authority's established office, subject to the president judge's power to order a hearing held in another more suitable location within the judicial district.

Statutes are summarized for public reference. Confirm current text at palegis.us. This page is attorney advertising, not legal advice.

Free case review

(717) 724-7503

Reviewed personally by Sean P. Quinlan, Esq. · PA attorney since 2001 · Reply usually same business day.

Free consultation · Calls answered now

The sooner we talk, the more we can do.

Every hour matters in a DUI or criminal case. Call directly and speak with Attorney Quinlan — not an intake desk.