ARD · Summary cases and court cases

Summary Case ARD vs. Court Case ARD in Pennsylvania

The rules, the decision-maker and the refusal path change with the type of case.

Free & confidential · Usually a same-day callback

  • Practicing since 2001
  • Member, National College for DUI Defense (NCDD)
  • Five-star reviewed
  • BBB A+ Rated

The short answer

They are two different procedures under two different sets of rules. In a court case the District Attorney moves and a Common Pleas judge decides. In the default summary-case track, the magisterial district judge admits the defendant, and the rules require no Commonwealth motion in that track — though admission is still subject to the written local procedures for the judicial district.

Side by side

IssueCourt case ARDSummary case ARD
Which rules applyPa.R.Crim.P. 310 through 320.Pa.R.Crim.P. 300, 301 and 302.
Who movesThe attorney for the Commonwealth moves under Rule 310.Default track: no Commonwealth motion is required. Local-option track: the District Attorney decides whether to move.
Who decidesA judge empowered to try court cases decides under Rule 313(C).Default track: the issuing authority. Local-option track: the judge in the court of common pleas.
Where it happensIn the court case before the judge.Default track: the proper issuing authority's office. Local-option track: the court of common pleas.
What happens on refusalThe case proceeds on the charges as provided by law.Default track: the case proceeds to trial under Chapter 4. Local-option track: it returns to the proper issuing authority under Chapter 4.
Local written proceduresCounty policy and statutes shape eligibility; Rules 310 through 320 govern the court-case process.Rule 300(D) requires written local procedures covering costs, restitution, conditions, record checking, record keeping and reporting, monthly reports, completion and termination.
Costs postureRule 316(a)(2) addresses costs and a reasonable administrative charge.The Rule 300 Comment says costs should be adjusted downward and kept minimal to reflect the minor nature of the summary case.

Court cases: Rules 310 through 320

Pa.R.Crim.P. 310 provides: "After criminal proceedings in a court case have been instituted, the attorney for the Commonwealth may move, before a judge empowered to try court cases, that the case be considered for accelerated rehabilitative disposition."[1]

Pa.R.Crim.P. 313(C): "After hearing the facts of the case, if the judge believes that it warrants accelerated rehabilitative disposition, the judge shall order the stenographer to reopen the record and shall state to the parties the conditions of the program. If the judge does not accept the case for accelerated rehabilitative disposition, the judge shall order that the case proceed on the charges as provided by law. No appeal shall be allowed from such order."[2]

The court-case process therefore requires both a Commonwealth motion and judicial acceptance. See who decides whether you get ARD in Pennsylvania.

Summary cases: Rules 300, 301 and 302

Pa.R.Crim.P. 300(A): "Unless the district attorney has elected, pursuant to paragraph(B)(1), that ARD in summary cases proceed in the court of common pleas, ARD in summary cases shall proceed in the office of the proper issuing authority as provided in Rule 301."[3]
Pa.R.Crim.P. 300(B): "The district attorney, by filing a certification with the president judge, may: (1) elect that ARD in summary cases proceed in the court of common pleas pursuant to Rule 302; and/or (2) designate certain classes of offenses or offenders, in addition to those statutorily excluded, that shall not be considered for summary case ARD."
Pa.R.Crim.P. 301(A): "Unless the district attorney has elected that ARD in summary cases proceed in the court of common pleas pursuant to Rule 300(B)(1), if the defendant is eligible for inclusion in an ARD program, the issuing authority may admit the defendant into an ARD program subject to the local procedures formulated by the president judge pursuant to Rule 300(D). If the issuing authority does not admit a defendant who is eligible for ARD, the issuing authority shall include in the monthly report required by Rule 300(D)(2)(e) a written statement of the reasons for not admitting the defendant."[4]
Pa.R.Crim.P. 301(B): "If the defendant declines to accept or fails to complete the program, or if the issuing authority does not admit the case for ARD, the case shall proceed to trial as provided in Chapter 4."

1. The magisterial district judge admits the defendant in the default track

The issuing authority makes the admission decision. There is no Commonwealth motion requirement in this track. That is a structurally different answer from a court case.

2. Declining an eligible defendant requires written reasons

Rule 301(A)'s second sentence is an accountability mechanism: a magisterial district judge who declines to admit an eligible defendant must put written reasons into the monthly report.

3. The District Attorney still shapes summary ARD

A Rule 300(B)(2) certification can designate classes of offenses or offenders as ineligible. The Rule 300 Comment states: "The district attorney is responsible for designating which classes of offenses or offenders may not be considered for ARD in summary cases." It adds: "The president judge, however, must implement without change the district attorney's elections made pursuant to paragraph (B)."

The local-option track: when the DA elects common pleas

Pa.R.Crim.P. 302(A): "When the district attorney has filed a certification to proceed by local option under Rule 300, after institution of criminal proceedings in a summary case, the issuing authority, the defendant, the defendant's attorney, or any other interested person may request that the district attorney consider the defendant's case for inclusion in the Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition Program."[5]
Pa.R.Crim.P. 302(C): "If the district attorney decides not to move for the defendant's inclusion in an ARD program, or if the defendant declines to accept or fails to complete the program, or if the judge does not accept the case for ARD, the case shall be referred to the proper issuing authority and shall proceed as provided in Chapter 4."

Local procedures must exist and be written down

Rule 300(D) requires the president judge of each judicial district to formulate local procedures for summary case ARD. They "shall be in writing, filed with the clerk of courts," and must at a minimum establish:

  • costs and administrative expenses;
  • procedures for restitution;
  • conditions of the program;
  • record checking, record keeping, and reporting requirements;
  • monthly reporting by each issuing authority; and
  • procedures for completion or termination.

The rules governing summary ARD in a county therefore exist on paper and can be obtained. They differ by judicial district, which is exactly why a local answer matters.

Costs should reflect the summary case

The Rule 300 Comment states: "the costs imposed on a defendant who is admitted into a summary case ARD program should not be the same as the costs imposed on a defendant for ARD in a court case, but rather should be adjusted downward and kept minimal to reflect the minor nature of the summary case."

Summary ARD is not available for every summary citation

The Rule 300 Comment notes that "there may be classes of offenses or offenders that are statutorily excluded," and gives 42 Pa.C.S. § 1520(a) as an example, describing it as excluding "cases charging offenses under Titles 34 and 75 from being considered for or included in the summary case adjudication alternative authorized by the statute." Two things are worth knowing about that reference. First, § 1520 authorizes the magisterial district judge's adjudication alternative program, which is a separate statutory diversion route from ARD. Second, the Comment's description is no longer current. Act 138 of 2024 amended § 1520(a) effective April 30, 2026, and the subsection now reads: "Except for cases charging offenses under 34 Pa.C.S. (relating to game), the magisterial district judge may, upon hearing the facts of a case, admit to an appropriate adjudication alternative authorized by this section persons charged with summary offenses." Title 75, the Vehicle Code, is no longer excluded. Whether a particular summary charge can be diverted still depends on the district attorney's certification under Rule 300(B)(2) and on the local procedures in your judicial district.

Summary ARD is not a general answer to every summary citation. Other routes may apply, and an attorney can confirm what is available for a particular charge in a particular county. This is not a closed list of what is or is not eligible.

Related pages

FAQ

Frequently asked questions.

Common questions about summary case ARD and court case ARD.

  • No. They use different procedures. Summary ARD is governed by Rules 300 through 302, while court-case ARD uses Rules 310 through 320. The Rule 300 Comment also points to 42 Pa.C.S. § 1520(a) — the magisterial district judge's adjudication alternative, which is a separate diversion route from ARD — as an example of a statutory exclusion. The Comment's description of that section is out of date: Act 138 of 2024 amended § 1520(a) effective April 30, 2026, so it now excludes only cases charging offenses under 34 Pa.C.S. (relating to game), not Title 75 Vehicle Code offenses. Availability for any particular summary charge still turns on the district attorney's certification under Rule 300(B)(2) and the local procedures for your judicial district.

  • In the default track, the issuing authority — the magisterial district judge — may admit an eligible defendant under Rule 301(A), subject to local procedures. No Commonwealth motion is required in that track. If the District Attorney has elected the local-option track under Rule 300(B)(1), the case proceeds in the court of common pleas instead.

  • Yes. Under Rule 300(B)(2), the District Attorney may file a certification designating additional classes of offenses or offenders that cannot be considered. The DA may also elect the common pleas local-option track under Rule 300(B)(1). The president judge must implement those elections without change.

  • If the defendant is eligible, Rule 301(A) requires the issuing authority to put written reasons for not admitting the defendant in the monthly report required by Rule 300(D)(2)(e). Under Rule 301(B), the case proceeds to trial as provided in Chapter 4.

  • The Rule 300 Comment says they should not be the same. It says summary ARD costs should be adjusted downward and kept minimal to reflect the minor nature of the summary case. Rule 300(D) requires the local written procedures to establish costs and administrative expenses.

  • Rule 300(D) requires each judicial district's president judge to formulate written procedures and file them with the clerk of courts. They exist on paper and can be obtained. They differ by judicial district, so a local answer matters.

Sources & statutory citations

  1. [1]Pa.R.Crim.P. 310 — After criminal proceedings in a court case have been instituted, the attorney for the Commonwealth may move, before a judge empowered to try court cases, that the case be considered for ARD. The Comment states that a request for inclusion into the program may be made to the district attorney by the defendant, the defendant's attorney, or an interested agency or institution. Whether the case is accepted is decided by the judge under Rule 313(C).
  2. [2]Pa.R.Crim.P. 313 — Under 313(C) the judge decides whether the case warrants ARD, and no appeal is allowed from an order declining it.
  3. [3]Pa.R.Crim.P. 300 — Summary case ARD. Rule 300(A) sets the issuing-authority track unless the district attorney elects common pleas under Rule 300(B)(1); Rule 300(B)(2) permits exclusions by certification; Rule 300(D) requires written local procedures.
  4. [4]Pa.R.Crim.P. 301 — Summary case ARD before the issuing authority. Rule 301(A) governs admission and written reasons for declining an eligible defendant; Rule 301(B) directs the case to trial if the defendant declines or does not complete the program, or is not admitted.
  5. [5]Pa.R.Crim.P. 302 — Local-option summary case ARD in the court of common pleas after a district attorney certification under Rule 300; Rule 302(C) governs referral back to the issuing authority.

Statutes are summarized for public reference. Confirm current text at palegis.us. This page is attorney advertising, not legal advice.

Free case review

(717) 724-7503

Reviewed personally by Sean P. Quinlan, Esq. · PA attorney since 2001 · Reply usually same business day.

Free consultation · Calls answered now

The sooner we talk, the more we can do.

Every hour matters in a DUI or criminal case. Call directly and speak with Attorney Quinlan — not an intake desk.