ARD · Admission and judicial acceptance
Who Decides Whether You Get ARD in Pennsylvania?
The District Attorney and the judge control separate gates. Both matter.
Free & confidential · Usually a same-day callback
- Practicing since 2001
- Member, National College for DUI Defense (NCDD)
- Five-star reviewed
- BBB A+ Rated
The short answer
Two separate decisions, not one. The attorney for the Commonwealth has to move for ARD, and the judge has to accept the case and set conditions you agree to. Either one can refuse. The judge's refusal cannot be appealed. The DA's refusal is not appealable in the ordinary sense either, but it can be challenged as an abuse of discretion, and that is a narrow and difficult challenge.
The common claim that ARD is the District Attorney's decision and the judge just ratifies it is wrong as a statement of the rules. The DA gate really is where most ARD decisions are made in practice — but it is not the only gate.
Gate 1: the Commonwealth must make the motion
Pa.R.Crim.P. 310 has no subsections. It reads in full:
"After criminal proceedings in a court case have been instituted, the attorney for the Commonwealth may move, before a judge empowered to try court cases, that the case be considered for accelerated rehabilitative disposition."[1]
The rule says "may move," not "shall move." Nothing in Chapter 3 lets a judge place a defendant into ARD in a court case without a Commonwealth motion.
Rule 310's Comment states: "A request for inclusion into the program may be made to the district attorney by the defendant, the defendant's attorney, or an interested agency or institution." The request comes from the defense side; the motion comes from the Commonwealth.
Gate 2: the judge makes an independent decision
Pa.R.Crim.P. 313(C): "After hearing the facts of the case, if the judge believes that it warrants accelerated rehabilitative disposition, the judge shall order the stenographer to reopen the record and shall state to the parties the conditions of the program. If the judge does not accept the case for accelerated rehabilitative disposition, the judge shall order that the case proceed on the charges as provided by law. No appeal shall be allowed from such order."[2]
Pa.R.Crim.P. 313(D): "After the stenographer reopens the record, the defendant shall thereupon state to the judge whether the defendant accepts the conditions and agrees to comply. If the statement is in the affirmative, the judge may grant the motion for accelerated rehabilitative disposition and shall enter an appropriate order as set forth in Rules 314 and 315. If the defendant answers in the negative, the judge shall proceed as set forth in Rule 317."[2]
The judge applies the judge's own belief about whether the case "warrants" ARD. Even after the defendant accepts the conditions, the rule says the judge "may grant" the motion rather than "shall grant" it.
Gate 2, continued: the conditions, and the defendant's own refusal
Pa.R.Crim.P. 316(a): "(a) The conditions of the program may include: (1) those imposed with respect to probation after conviction of a crime, including restitution, except that a fine may not be imposed; (2) the imposition of costs and a reasonable charge relating to the expense of administering the program; and (3) such other conditions as may be agreed to by the parties."[3]
Pa.R.Crim.P. 316(b): "(b) The period of such program for any defendant shall not exceed two years."[3]
Rule 316's current text comes from an amendment adopted April 21, 2026, effective November 1, 2026. The rule now prints lowercase subsection letters, so the two-year cap is Rule 316(b).
Rule 313(D) also gives the defendant a decision: the defendant must state whether the conditions are accepted. A negative answer sends the judge to Rule 317. A defendant can therefore refuse the conditions rather than accept the program.
The Rule 316 Comment addresses indigent participants
"The practice has been to permit qualified individuals who are indigent to participate in the ARD program without payment of costs or charges. The 1983 amendment is not intended to change this practice; rather, it is intended that such practice will continue."
What eligibility actually depends on
The Committee Introduction to Chapter 3 states:
"These rules do not specify those classes of offenses or offenders that are eligible or ineligible for inclusion in the ARD program. In general, the district attorney has the responsibility for determining which cases will be recommended for entry into the ARD program. See Commonwealth v. Lutz, 495 A.2d 928 (Pa. 1985)."
The Introduction describes the intended candidate this way:
"These rules contemplate that ordinarily the defendants eligible for the ARD program are first offenders who lend themselves to treatment and rehabilitation rather than punishment and that the crime charged is relatively minor and does not involve a serious breach of the public trust."
Eligibility therefore does not come from the rules alone. It comes from county District Attorney policy, from statute for particular case types, from each judicial district's own local ARD procedures under Pa.R.Crim.P. 300(C) and (D), and — in summary cases — from the DA's certification. Other routes and local requirements may apply, so what controls in one county may not control in the next. The summary-case track is explained in summary case ARD vs. court case ARD.
Later decisions are also unappealable
Pa.R.Crim.P. 318(C): "When the defendant is brought before the court, the judge shall afford the defendant an opportunity to be heard. If the judge finds that the defendant has committed a violation of a condition of the program, the judge may order, when appropriate, that the program be terminated, and that the attorney for the Commonwealth shall proceed on the charges as provided by law. No appeal shall be allowed from such order."[4]
Two defense points come from the same rule. Rule 318(A) requires the Commonwealth to file a motion to start a violation proceeding. Rule 318(B) provides that such a motion "must be filed during the period of the program or, if filed thereafter, must be filed within a reasonable time after the alleged violation was committed."
The reward at the end: dismissal and expungement
Pa.R.Crim.P. 319 has no subsections and reads in full:
"When the defendant shall have completed satisfactorily the program prescribed and complied with its conditions, the defendant may move the court for an order dismissing the charges. This motion shall be supported by affidavit of the defendant and by certification of the agency or person charged with supervising the defendant's program, if any. A copy of the motion shall be served on the attorney for the Commonwealth who shall within 30 days after service advise the judge of any objections to the motion, serving a copy of such objections on the defendant or the defendant's attorney. If there are no objections filed within the 30-day period, the judge shall thereafter dismiss the charges against the defendant. If there are objections filed with regard to the dismissal of charges, the judge shall proceed as set forth in Rule 318."[5]
Pa.R.Crim.P. 320(A): "When the judge orders the dismissal of the charges against the defendant, the judge also shall order the expungement of the defendant's arrest record, subject to the provisions of paragraph (B)."[6]
The judge orders expungement on successful completion. The client does not have to file an expungement petition.
Some counties still expect a motion or a proposed order, and that is something the defense attorney handles. The Rule 320 Comment states: "The cases have held that a defendant's arrest record shall be expunged upon successful completion of an ARD program, unless the Commonwealth presents compelling reasons why the arrest record should be retained."
The plain-language answer
Two things have to happen — the District Attorney has to agree to move for ARD, and the judge has to accept the case and set conditions you agree to. Either one can say no. The judge's no is final and cannot be appealed. The DA's no can only be attacked as an abuse of discretion, which rarely succeeds. That is exactly why the application is worth doing properly the first time. An attorney can confirm how this applies to your case.
Related pages
FAQ
Frequently asked questions.
Common questions about who decides ARD admission in Pennsylvania.
Both have a separate role. The attorney for the Commonwealth must move for ARD under Rule 310, and the judge must accept the case and set conditions the defendant agrees to under Rules 313(C) and 313(D). The DA gate is where most ARD decisions are made in practice, but the judge is not merely ratifying the DA's decision.
It depends on who refused. If the judge does not accept the case, Rule 313(C) provides that "No appeal shall be allowed from such order," and Rule 318(C) says the same about an order terminating the program after a violation proceeding. If the District Attorney refuses to move for ARD, there is no appeal as of right, but the refusal can be challenged as an abuse of discretion. Under Commonwealth v. Lutz, 495 A.2d 928 (Pa. 1985), the DA's decision stands absent an abuse of that discretion "involving some criteria for admission to ARD wholly, patently and without doubt unrelated to the protection of society and/or the likelihood of a person's success in rehabilitation, such as race, religion or other such obviously prohibited considerations." That is a narrow and difficult challenge. Other routes may apply depending on the county and the facts.
Yes. A Commonwealth motion is the first gate, not the final decision. Under Rule 313(C), the judge hears the facts and applies the judge's own belief about whether the case warrants ARD. If the judge does not accept it, the case proceeds on the charges and no appeal is allowed.
Rule 316(a) permits probation-type conditions including restitution, costs and a reasonable charge relating to program administration, and other conditions agreed to by the parties. A fine may not be imposed. Under Rule 316(b), the program cannot exceed two years.
No. Rule 316(a)(1) permits probation-type conditions including restitution, but states: "except that a fine may not be imposed." Costs and a reasonable administrative charge are separate from a fine.
No. Under Rule 320(A), when the judge orders dismissal after successful completion, the judge also orders expungement of the arrest record, subject to paragraph (B). The client does not have to file an expungement petition. Some counties still expect a motion or proposed order, which the defense attorney handles.
Yes. Rule 310's Comment says the defendant, the defendant's attorney, or an interested agency or institution may request inclusion from the district attorney. That request is different from the formal motion: the motion to the judge comes from the attorney for the Commonwealth.
Related pages
First-offense DUI in PA
BAC tiers, ARD, and how to keep it off your record.
Second-offense DUI in PA
Mandatory jail, 12–18 month suspension, and where the defense wins.
ARD & Act 58 of 2025
How § 3802(h) created a separate DUI-following-diversion offense.
Criminal defense
Beyond DUI — every PA misdemeanor and felony.
Areas we serve
Cumberland, Dauphin, and York County coverage.
Free consultation
Talk to Attorney Quinlan today.
Sources & statutory citations
- [1]Pa.R.Crim.P. 310 — After criminal proceedings in a court case have been instituted, the attorney for the Commonwealth may move, before a judge empowered to try court cases, that the case be considered for ARD. The Comment states that a request for inclusion into the program may be made to the district attorney by the defendant, the defendant's attorney, or an interested agency or institution. Whether the case is accepted is decided by the judge under Rule 313(C).
- [2]Pa.R.Crim.P. 313 — Under 313(C) the judge decides whether the case warrants ARD, and no appeal is allowed from an order declining it.
- [3]Pa.R.Crim.P. 316 — amended April 21, 2026, effective November 1, 2026. Rule 316(b): "The period of such program for any defendant shall not exceed two years." Rule 316(a)(1) permits probation-type conditions including restitution but provides that a fine may not be imposed.
- [4]Pa.R.Crim.P. 318 — Procedure on Charge of Violation of Conditions. Under Rule 318(A) the attorney for the Commonwealth may move where the defendant is alleged to have violated a condition of the program; under 318(C) the judge shall afford the defendant an opportunity to be heard, and on a finding of violation may order that the program be terminated, with no appeal allowed from that order.
- [5]Pa.R.Crim.P. 319 — Procedure for dismissal of charges after successful completion of an ARD program. Rule 320(B) measures the Commonwealth's objection window from service of a motion for dismissal under this rule.
- [6]Pa.R.Crim.P. 320 — Rule 320(A) directs the judge who dismisses the charges after successful ARD completion to also order expungement of the defendant's arrest record, and Rule 320(B) calls this 'the automatic expungement.' Under Rule 320(B) the attorney for the Commonwealth's objections are filed with the judge, together with any objections to dismissal, within 30 days after service of a motion for dismissal under Rule 319 — not after service of the expungement order. Rule 320(C) then requires a hearing on the objections. The order must contain the information required by Rule 490(C) in summary cases and Rule 790(C) in court cases.
Statutes are summarized for public reference. Confirm current text at palegis.us. This page is attorney advertising, not legal advice.
Free consultation · Calls answered now
The sooner we talk, the more we can do.
Every hour matters in a DUI or criminal case. Call directly and speak with Attorney Quinlan — not an intake desk.